2026 MARKET TRENDS
Umbrella & Excess Liability
Key Takeaways
- Nuclear verdicts and social inflation continue to drive claim severity higher, keeping umbrella pricing firm across most regions
- Carriers are increasing underlying auto liability requirements, often to $500,000–$1 million
- Capacity for limits above $25 million remains tight, driving more placements into the E&S market
- Households with youthful drivers, high-performance vehicles, yachts or rental properties face heightened underwriting scrutiny
- High-severity jurisdictions such as New York, Florida and California continue to influence both pricing and availability
Overall, the 2026 market is expected to resemble 2025, with disciplined underwriting, limited high-limit capacity and increased use of the E&S market.
Market Conditions
The umbrella insurance market remains firm heading into 2026 as litigation severity, social inflation and rising verdict values continue to drive loss costs. Nuclear verdicts exceeding $10 million have increased more than 50% year over year, with median awards frequently above $40–50 million. These trends are prompting carriers to adopt stricter underwriting and to place greater emphasis on auto-related exposures, which remain the leading cause of catastrophic liability claims.
Carriers are increasing minimum underlying liability requirements, particularly for auto. Many now require $500,000–$1 million in underlying auto bodily injury limits to qualify for umbrella coverage. Households with youthful drivers, high-performance or exotic vehicles, yachts, rental properties or domestic employees may also face higher requirements or reduced capacity.
Capacity for limits above $25 million remains constrained. Higher-limit towers often require layered structures or participation from E&S carriers, who provide added flexibility but require more detailed submissions, higher minimum premiums and stronger underlying limits. Overall, the 2026 market is expected to resemble 2025, with disciplined underwriting, limited high-limit capacity and increased use of the E&S market for complex or higher-hazard profiles.
Claims Trends
Claims severity continues to rise due to social inflation, an increase in nuclear verdicts and broader participation in litigation funding. Auto remains the primary driver of catastrophic liability, particularly multi-vehicle accidents and high-severity pedestrian or cyclist incidents in metro areas. These losses disproportionately impact the lower layers of umbrella towers, leading carriers to reduce line sizes or transition accounts to the E&S market.
Ground handling and incidental liability exposures remain costly, especially where high-value vehicles or recreational equipment contribute to large losses. Litigation funding continues to increase defense costs, prolong settlement timelines and raise the likelihood of high jury awards.
Geographic & Regional Differences
Regional differences in the liability environment are playing a significant role in umbrella pricing and availability.
Umbrella insurance rates are expected to remain firm heading into 2026 as carriers respond to rising claim severity, continued social inflation and pressure from nuclear verdict trends. Capacity for higher limits remains constrained, particularly for auto-heavy households and those in high-severity jurisdictions. As a result, disciplined underwriting and increased reliance on the E&S market will continue.
Impacts & Customer Considerations
As personal liability exposures expand, umbrella coverage remains a critical layer of protection for high-net-worth families. Proactive planning can help households secure more favorable terms in a firm market.
Consider a unified program with a high-net-worth carrier to improve pricing and streamline coverage to help support alignment of underlying limits across the program
Increase underlying auto liability limits to support umbrella capacity and avoid gaps
Address youthful-driver risks with training, telematics and careful vehicle assignments
Prepare documentation early for higher-risk exposures such as yachts, rental properties, high-performance vehicles or domestic employees
Competitive conditions are strongest in the Midwest, while households in the Northeast and Southeast benefit from strong submissions and proactive risk management
Brown & Brown, Inc. and all its affiliates, do not provide legal, regulatory, tax guidance and/or advice. If legal advice, counsel or representation is needed, the services of a legal professional should be sought. The information in this document is intended to provide a general overview of the topics and services contained herein. Brown & Brown, Inc. and all its affiliates make no representation or warranty as to the accuracy or completeness of the document and undertakes no obligation to update or revise the document based upon new information or future changes.
Legal Notices | Your Privacy Rights | Do Not Sell/Share/Limit Disclosure | Cookies Policy | Accessibility | Commitment to EEO | Medicare Disclaimer | Ethics Hotline | Consumer Health Data Privacy | CA Notice at Collection